
Aston Villa 1874

Blackburn Rovers 1875

Bacup Borough 1879

Preston North End 1880

Burnley 1882

Millwall 1885

Sheffield Wednesday
(1887)

Newcastle 1892

Portsmouth 1898

Bradford City 1903
England's Scots Clubs
- the first forty years
(under development)
Some football clubs are founded. But they are also made by contributions, some on- and some off-field. So here is a question. Name me a club in Scotland founded by an Englishman. It is a struggle yet Scots in England have done, have been responsible for both, a few of which have come and gone but a number, a good number, at least twenty, a score, exist to today.
And at current clubs it began in Birmingham with Aston Villa with the clue the lion-rampant on its badge. There George Ramsay by 1875 with club experience in Glasgow's came across the members otherwise of an Aston church cricket team having a park kick-about, joined in, showing his superiority of technique, of knowledge, and then was joined by the Lindsay brothers from Golspie in Sutherland in the first season of the club that emerged and then in finding and developing its first ground. And after and a short gap after playing, when the club was essentially run by Scots, including future founder of the English Football League and hence, by example, all leagues, Perthshire's William McGregor, again Ramsay was to become the Club Secretary/Manager, a role he was to hold with multiple successes in League and Cup for fully forty years.
Bolton Wanderers was founded the same year as The Villa, 1874, originally as a church school team. But in 1877 there was a break from the church and a club emerged that is said, hence Wanderers, to have struggled to find a permanent ground yet by 1880 and settling at its Pikes Lane ground was already recruiting Scots players, paid to play. First came Glasgow-born Willie Struthers of Rangers, who a year earlier had been, with the Vallance brothers, Peter Campbell, Moses McNeill and Hugh McIntyre, in its losing Cup-eleven. And the following season he was joined by three more Scots, there would be four in the squad until 1884, rising to five in 1884-5, seven the following one, Struthers briefly Club Secretary, and nine, so much of a First Team, in 1889-90 with the club a founder member of the Football League the season before.
Moreover, it would be Peter Campbell, already in 1879 for a single season, and Hugh McIntyre, once more in 1880 for six, who would be the start of much the same pattern at Blackburn Rovers. And the latter would soon be joined by two more countrymen as first-teamers, rising to three more in 1884-5 and four more in 1886-7, as the club, by then also under the guidance of Dumfries-born Thomas Mitchell, would for a third year in a row take the FA Cup, indeed see off Queen's Park Scottish challenge. Moreover, Mitchell and club Cup-win once more in 1890 and again 1891 with by then respectively four and six Scots in the winning teams.
And meanwhile there had been the rise of Everton. It would, twelve years after foundation, win the Football League in 1891 and in 1893 be runner-up in the FA Cup. And it would do so with sixteen Scots in the squad in the former season and twenty-one in the latter, with six of them on the field for the 0-1 final and the league-win at least based on the coaching of David Waugh. He as a player, a forward, had in 1883 moved South from Glasgow to the Bolton area, first to Great Lever, then Padiham, before in 1887 joining Burnley for a season and Everton for one more until he was injured and with the club stuttering the Board appointed him coach. And the effect was not long in showing itself. The club finished eighth in 1889, second in 1890, Champions the following season and then he was gone, not from Liverpool but the club. It would not win a trophy for another dozen years.
Which takes us from one of today's largest clubs on the list to one of the smallest, Irwell Springs and Bacup F.C. that were, Bacup Borough that is. And here the story is simple. It is one of origin. The original Irwell Springs was founded in 1879 by the Rankine brothers, John and Robert and as the team of the local dye works. The boys are said in their native Scotland to have played for Vale of Leven but they had been born and brought up in Rutherglen, their work as dyers possibly taking then not to The Vale but Renton before the move to and settling in Lancashire.
And as football in Bacup was starting so east in Sunderland another Scot was there doing the same. He, James Allan, was Ayr-born in 1857, growing up in Tarbolton, the son of a shoe-maker. He is then said to have been accepted to study medicine at Glasgow University, playing the game in and around the city with Busby, Oxford, like Villa's Ramsay, both clubs founded in 1873, and at East Kilbride.

Bolton Wanderers 1874

Everton 1878

Sunderland 1879

Tottenham Hotspur 1882

Bury 1885

Arsenal 1886

Southport 1888

Liverpool 1892

West Ham 1900

Chelsea 1905
But, essentially dropping out without graduating, he left to become a teacher Down South. And there on the banks of the Wear in 1979, so aged twenty-two, he founded the closed and amateur Sunderland and District Teachers' Association Football Club, which the following year became Sunderland Association Football Club, open to all, many of them Scots, including, it seems, his elder brother, William and by 1885, if not earlier, turning, with three imported Scots, in essence professional. And James six years later would then in 1888 do it all again. Having fallen out with his original club, he helped formed a second, Sunderland Albion, which also imported Scots talent but this time failed, dissolved in 1892.
Meantime, in 1880 back in North-East Lancashire there had been not the foundation of Preston North End, it having been formed as a cricket club, but its decision that year to focus on football. And that was largely tied up with the chairmanship by a local cotton-mill-manager, by then thirty-year-old, former-player, then Lieutenant later Major William Sudell. But there seems to have been another in background and a Scot. His name was James McDade, in 1881 a twenty-six year-old tinsmith born in Mearns, growing up in Neilston, perhaps a player locally with Barrhead or similar, who had probably arrived in the town to work in his trade but where his footballing abilities where quickly recognised, both on-field and then by 1882-3 as a trainer. And by then Sudell was already bringing the first of his players from North of the Border, initially from Ayrshire, perhaps guided by McDade, and giving them sinecure jobs at his works. And they would be followed by several more from Edinburgh, resulting by 1884-5 in ten on the books, including the Ross brothers, by 1888, when PNE would win the inaugural Football League, it rising to twelve, John Goodall now added, and, and after a second championship, to thirteen in 1890-91 with, on Sudell leaving the club in 1893, that number being ten.
And as Sudell and McDade had begun their cooperation, the latter in 1883 moving from Preston to Chorley, where perhaps uncoincidentally its rugby club converted to football, in 1882 two more clubs had come into being. The first was Burnley, just twenty miles or so up the road. The the second was Tottenham Hotspur in London.
Burnley was another to convert from the oval- to the round-ball. And by the following year it was already de facto professional importing three Scots that season, retaining one, and an incredible eleven more the following campaign. And whilst that number would fall, it was would for two decades never drop below six and be back in the teens by the League's start and for most of the next decade. In other words Burnley was until the turn of the century on-field quite simply a "Scots" club, remaining so in playing-style at least for much of the next seventy-years.
As to Spurs, the first southern club on this list, the foundation story has as its origin three what were still very much lads, who played cricket together. One was a Londoner, a second was from a Suffolk family and the third was an only just Diasporan Scot, fourteen year-old John Connell Anderson. In fact the founders were eleven in number and two were Scots, John and his brother, Tom, a year younger. They were the two eldest children of parents both from Lochwinnoch, who had move South the year before John had been born, 1868. Perhaps he had even been conceived North of the Border. And John would remain a club-player until 1892, by then only twenty-four but his on-field time done and just three years before the club turned professional at the very end of 1895 but two before the first Scots professionals seemed to arrive. And from then the flow would continue, rising to ten in the squad in 1898, as the club had joined the Southern League in 1896, and before, three years later, it would become the only non-League one ever to win the FA Cup, with that day five Scots in the team including John Cameron, as player-manager a new concept, in the top-flight at least, and three more in the squad.
Now, at this point there would be something of a formational hiatus, albeit only of three years. But first let us go to the year before Tottenham had won the FA Cup so 1900, a final played between Bury and Southampton with not seven but eight Scots on the field, five not four, including both full-backs and both outer-halves, for victorious Bury. Bury itself had been founded as far back as 1885, had joined the Lancashire League in 1889 and been promoted to the Football League in 1894. And from the start it had been professional in that first season importing three Scots, with a fourth local and thought to be English. And Bury would continue to be seen to employ talent from Caledonia for three seasons, then seemingly take a five campaign break before restarting and climbing by the middle of the 1890s to ten, actually eleven in the squad. Which takes us to the odd-man-out in all this. His name was George Ross, a wing-half, who would captain the team to its second and record-breaking Cup win in 1903. By then he was thirty-three. He would play on to thirty-five. But he had begun at sixteen in a Bury feeder cum reserve team, having been brought up in the town and before that in Darwen, his father a police-officer. But his parents were both Scots with George born before they left to come South in Mulben, in the deep countryside north of Keith, from where they came, his father on the land. So George Ross was an Anglo, one quite possibly good enough to play for his actual homeland, an alternative alongside Alex Raisbeck to Andy Aitken but quite possibly one never known about by the Scottish FA so never considered.
And then came Millwall, the other club with the lion logo, a degree of denial and even from foundation enough simple but sharp proof to the contrary to fill boots, football and other. The club is now based on the banks of the Thames but in South London. But it began on the north bank, on the Isle of Dogs. There from 1872 John Morton, already with a canning-factory in Aberdeen, opened several more facilities on the island. It would soon after the docks be its largest employer, with a number of Scots in waves brought South to get things started and football clearly brought with them. Millwall, as Millwall Rovers, emerging as a team originally called Iona, was founded in 1885. Its first Secretary was Jaspar Sexton, the son of a local, Irish pub-owner. Its Honorary Secretary was William Henderson, a tinsmith, so a sealer of cans, from Edinburgh, its players included Alex Gordon probably from Aberdeenshire and George Syme from Alloa. Its captain was Duncan Hean from Dundee. And its President was William Murray Leslie, the local doctor, born and brought up just north of Inverness by Munlochy on the Black Isle. It was an almost full, Caledonian house.
So now we are but half-way and come to Arsenal, but not today's but the previous life in then semi-rural Kent, so south of the river. Built, understandably for safety reasons, outside the city of London was the Royal Ordnance factory, supplier of explosive materials, weapons and ammunition to the Armed Service, drawing in expertise and labour from throughout the British Isles. And it was to there that a young engineer came. His name was David Danskin. He was from Fife, born in Burntisland, raised in Leslie, apprenticed in 'Caldy. And it was in that same town he had played football for Kirkcaldy Wanderers. That is before in 1885 heading South to work in the Dial Square section of the Woolwich works and the following year in December to be instrumental in the formation, from an existing cricket club, and first captain of Dial Square F.C., which the following month became Royal Arsenal, in 1893 Woolwich Arsenal and in 1913 with the move across the Thames simply Arsenal F.C.. By then had some eight Scots on the payroll, the count having fallen from eleven two years earlier and fourteen in 1890-91. Indeed the club, starting with three, Danskin one of them, had rapid built up the numbers over the previous four campaigns, even prior to turning officially professional in 1891 with Danskin himself forced out to start a short-lived local rival and eventually to move to, live out the rest of his life and be buried in Coventry.
But now we move back north, and to one of the more contentiously Scots clubs, Sheffield Wednesday. The Wednesday, as it was then known, had been founded in 1867 out of an even earlier cricket club but it did not play Association, London Rules football but Sheffield Rules for the next decade. Indeed the first time it entered the FA Cup would not be until 1880 and it actually performed quite well. After a walkover against an otherwise busy Queen's Park in the first round it beat none other than Blackburn Rovers in the second, Turton in the third before succumbing to Darwen in the next. And it had done already with a Scot in the team. In 1876 the club had recruited from Glasgow football the Scottish internationalist, J.J. Lang, probably not the World's first professional, that was probably the Sheffield player, Jack Hunter, but the World's first to relocate to be played to play. Lang would remain at the club until 1882. Wednesday would the same season make the Cup semi-final, Lang in the side, only this time to lose to McIntyre's Blackburn Rovers. But from then it would be a slide, fourth round the following year, second round in 1883-4, third round but with a bye the next, first round defeat in 1885-6, then a year of non-participation. Truth was that the club was being swept aside the newly emerging, professional clubs, was losing players to them and could hardly get a team together. Indeed, after at the beginning of April 1887 a 0-16 home defeat with just ten men available action was needed. On 22nd April a meeting was held and the decision taken for open professionalism. The club came back together. The FA Cup was re-entered and the club made the sixth round before defeat to Preston North End.
However by then the Football League boat had been missed. In fact no Sheffield team took part. And then four things happened. The first was the foundation with the active participation of Charles Clegg, the Chairmen of Wednesday, and soon to be the FA Vice-President, of Sheffield United. The Wednesday had competition and it concentrated minds. The second was that the club then topped its alternative league, the Alliance, in 1890. The third was that it reached the FA Cup final only to lose with an all English eleven very heavily and again to Blackburn Rovers. And the fourth was that it began to recruit Scots. Four arrived in 1890-91 even as or perhaps due to the club finishing thirteenth of thirteen . That number became seven the following season as the team rose back to fourth and was "elected" to the Football League. Then it became eleven, eleven again, eight and nine as the team held its own for four seasons in its new First Division home. And it was also nine when in 1896 the club reached the FA Cup Final once more, this time with five of them on the field and to win, interestingly as Sheffield United went the other way. It on foundation had six Scots on its books but by 1898, as it would itself take the FA Cup, there was just one, and he in the squad but not the team.
And now it is back across the country to Lancashire and to a club that was in the Football League from 1921 to 1978 in its third and fourth tiers and is now outwith it in the sixth. It is Southport, actually founded at two meetings in June 1888, a third at the end of August and as Southport Central. And the person to have at the second June gathering suggested the original name was Robert McGown. He had been Secretary of local High Park, a football club, which exists to this day, and he appears to have been a Scot. Moreover, it also appears that, whilst he had married in Southport in 1879, lived just to the north of the town and died still in Lancashire perhaps in 1899 or maybe 1925, it is not clear, in 1861 he had been a bleacher to trade and in 1851, as a wee bairn, had been living, on Burn St.; all in none other than the Vale of Leven, indeed the parish of Bonhill, which is where in 1849 he had also been born. Furthermore, in the August meeting there was the announcement that "foreign talent" would be introduced by paying players, the person to have made it was Mr. J. B. Watson, a John Brydon(e) Watson, Gentleman. He would die on Ash St. in Southport in 1895, aged sixty but again was a Scot, born in 1825 in Tranent.
And that "foreign talent" would not be long in coming. The Liverpool Echo of 18th January 1890 would report the arrival of the 10st 6ib, 5' 6", "twenty-one year old" forward from Vale of Leven, the club by then literally across the river from Bonhill. And it was not to one of the Merseyside clubs but Southport Central. And, whilst But there is no sign that he, Charlie McLaren, had been a regular first-teamer at Vale of Leven, although perhaps a reserve, hence perhaps his arrival at Southport rather than a larger club, like so many of his footballing peers at and in The Vale, in 1881 he had been a print-field worker living at home at Milton, half-way between Bonhill and Jamestown , with a Bonhill-born, dyer father, Allan, and a Renton-born mother, Elizabeth. And whilst his parents would live out their lives in Scotland, Charlie would never return. Not recorded anywhere in 1891 in 1894 he married Southport-girl, in 1901 was house-painter in the town, as he was in 1911, dying in in 1936 still in the town.
But there are clearly problems. The first is that in 1861 he is said to have been fourteen, so born in 1866 and therefore in 1890 have been not twenty-one but twenty-three or even twenty-four. Howover, stating that he was twenty-four on his 1891 marriage-certificate, with indeed a dyer father called Allan, looks like a continuation of the same lie. The second is that Charlie's elder brother, Alex, also Milton-born, also untraceable in 1891, in 1895 married a local girl in Manchester, started a family and in 1901 and 1911 was working still there as a Stevedore . So it may have been our Charlie had indeed come south to Lancashire by 1890 or even earlier, perhaps with brother, to try his hand as a professional footballer, had failed at the larger clubs and simply ended up at Southport. Indeed the difference in Charlie's given and actual age and therefore birth-date may even have been football-related; an attempt, as often would be the case, to make him seem younger than he was, with more longevity than actually was the case.
Football had already come to Tyneside by the early 1880s. East End had been formed in 1881, West End the following year and very quickly with Scots involvement, a half-dozen by 1886, a dozen or so by 1890. But it would not be until 1892 that the two early clubs combined to form Newcastle United, from when The Toon would become more Caledonian still not just in personnel, albeit actually not greatly so, up from eight or so between them, but much more in playing-style, not least with in December 1895 as Club Secretary of Edinburgh's first on- and then off-field Frank Watt. But it was not to be not immediate. When he arrived there were already twelve Scots on the books, reduced to nine the following season. Watt was having a clear-out but would also recruit. In 1897-8 the number stood at fourteen, fourteen again in 1898-9, in 1901-2 fourteen too - including Andy Aitken, the Gardners, McColl and a young Veitch - and in 1907-8 seventeen, amongst them a number from five year earlier plus Howie, Lawrence, McWilliam and more. And his First Teams would in that same period field up to eights Scots, captained initially by Aitken and then more or less to The Great War by the, same very Scots Diasporan Colin Campbell Mckechnie Veitch. Moreover, from as early as 1903, and with real success, they were to be trained by Fife via Kilmarnock's James Quar McPherson, whose son of the same name would continue the role to 1937. This was as Frank Watt, "the man who made Newcastle United" had in 1930, after thirty-five years at the helm and aged seventy-five himself stepped down to pass away still in his adopted city two years later.
It is commonish knowledge that Liverpool on-field was started by Scots. There is no gain-saying the Team of the Macs. But it is perhaps less known why or why least as the main reason. Simply put Everton, then playing at the Anfield ground, was in 1890 and 1891 asked to pay a more than seven-fold, escalating level of rent for its stadium-use. It was also lucky enough to find land nearby, Mere Green Field, to rent, there to build a new ground, Goodison Park, and with an interest-free loan from one of its Committee-members. It meant that by the summer of 1892 Anfield stood empty, was costing money and something would be done. That was to create, to invent a new team but with virtually no players to hand decent ones had to found from somewhere. That somewhere, as had been the case for Everton, was Scotland with sixteen brought South. It was a pool with enough ability to win the Lancashire League at first try and join the Football League's second division. It was also with a changing but not dissimilar pool that Liverpool would win promotion to the First Division in 1896, then be attractive enough to tempt Geordie Tom Watson across from Sunderland and before that both Newcastle West and East End, where at all three clubs he as Secretary had been an avid recruiter of Scots. And finally it would in 1901 prove enough for Liverpool to win the League title with Watson still in charge as he would be until 1915, by when he still had a dozen or so from North of the Border on the pay-roll with in the interim never fewer that six.
And nor would Liverpool be the only major, modern club to follow a similar path but in the meantime there would be three more to do it their own ways but from the same source. England's footballing south was outwith London by the mid-1890s beginning to wake up, not least the South Coast. Football had arrived in Southampton in 1878, brought by shipyard workers brought from Scotland. But a decade later the yards were gone, their football with them but leaving a trace that in 1885 had been enough to see the formation from St. Mary's church a team that, when in 1894 the Southern League was formed, it as Southampton St. Mary's had joined.
Moreover, professional Brighton and Hove Albion would be formed in 1901 but it had in two stages filled a gap created by the dissolution of Brighton United. Having been formed in 1897, United had joined the Southern League in 1898 only to collapse a season and half later after trying to do a "Liverpool". For 1898-9 it had recruited nine Scots. Even for the following, terminal season five had remained. Then in 1900 and very briefly the amateur Brighton & Hove Rangers emerged before in 1901 semi-professional Albion took over and for good.
And meantime in Portsmouth its club had also come into being, in 1898 once more, with the organised game first having been played in the now city in 1893 by Portsmouth Association Football Club and then in the early and mid-1890 s by both Portsmouth Town and by the military Royal Artillery Portsmouth. The latter had joined the Southern League in 1897, would be promoted from its Second Division at the end of the season only to be relegated and disbanded at the end of 1898-9, with its place effectively taken by the town's new team. And it would step into the breach already with eight Scots on the payroll, the first being probably a young Tom Wilkie from Edinburgh but the most influential the veteran Bob Blyth from Glenbuck, that is despite the former's on-field contribution over five, perhaps six seasons and the latter's of only two.
Blyth, uncle of a certain Bill Shankly, would arrive, a wing-half, in 1899 at twenty-nine from five seasons at Preston North End to captain the South Coast club. He would be player-only at newly-built Fratton Park for two more years and, as the pool of his countrymen was maintained, step up to player-manager as the Southern League was won in 1902 and the Western League in 1903, after hanging up his boots remaining as the latter until 1904 and then seem to step back to run pubs/hotels in the city. But he, in the background, would become a director of the club in 1909, see it suffer relegation for a season, and, with it in the Football League from 1921, he stepping up to chairman in 1924, promotion to its First Division. That is before retiring at sixty-five in 1934, watching the club in 1939 win the FA Cup and, still in the city, dying in 1941.
If Millwall had been the East End of London's earliest surviving Scots club not it but the sources of the next were not long in coming. By 1892 the Lea-mouth repair yard of Donald Currie, London-based but Greenock-born, would see the formation of work's team, Castle Swifts. Indeed it was a club formed specifically for the yard workers, many of whom were Scots brought down to work there by the Castle Line and then Union-Castle Line shipping magnate and perhaps as something of a final retirement gift from him to them. He had turned sixty five in 1890 and maybe at sixty-seven was thinking of fully stepping back.
In fact for its first season Castle Swifts F.C. was to be a clear of Scots and local Londoners, that is before better players, presumably with the financial backing of Currie himself, were brought in, several from Millwall and Scots; that is as the club in November 1894 went professional and was renamed Old Castle Swifts. But the following year finances were cut, presumably also by Currie, the club was rapidly dissolved and into the space stepped a certain Arnold Hills.
He was the owner of Thames Ironworks and Shipbuilding Company, the yard on the opposite bank of the river to that of Currie. Moreover, Hills' new club, named simply Thames Ironworks F.C., was to take over the Castle Swifts ground and take on several of its players. And it would also bring in more Scots, by 1898 eleven or so, as the club joined the Southern League and, having turned professional, was promoted at first attempt. But again the new club was also to be short-lived. In 1900 it too was disbanded but as before with a parachute. It would be West Ham United, formed in July that same year, its first manager, Syd King, Ironwork's last, players, Scots and all, also transferring across and the new entity able seamlessly from that autumn also able take the former's place in the Southern League's First Division.
But if continuity or rather flow had been the watchword in East London, two hundred miles north in Bradford it seems to have been the opposite. It is interesting, with the exception of in Sheffield, how late organised, round-ball football seems to have come to West Yorkshire. Perhaps it was the influence the oval-ball version, perhaps the problems Sheffield had created for itself but, although Barnsley existed from 1887, even Leeds as Leeds City had not come into being until 1904, Huddersfield in 1908, Halifax in 1911, whilst for Bradford it was 1903 and from a Press suggestion. It had come from a by-then local journalist buut his name was James Whyte cum White, James Tweedie Whyte and therein lies the clue to his origins. He was a Scot, a Lanarkshire-man, indeed his parents, his father a joiner and his mother a milner, hailed from Lanark itself. He, however, had been born in 1863 in Cambusnethan by Wishaw and grown up in Airdrie.
As to the creation of the club itself, the original suggestion for it is said actually to have come to Whyte from the FA but he had carried it forward. Indeed he was to be the club's first Secretary. However that initial Scottishness would go far further. The Bantams' first manager would be Renton's Robert Campbell, who would immediately bring in seven Scots, increasing that number to ten the following season. Furthermore, he was in 1905 to move on, replaced by one of his players, Newmains' Peter O'Rourke. And he was to remain in place until 1921, increasing the Scots contingent to a maximum of fifteen in 1914-15, having won the Second Division in 1908 and on a replay in 1911 the FA Cup with that day his captain Govan's Jimmy Speirs, ex. Rangers one of fully eight Scots in the club's on-field team. Moreover, the opposition that day was Newcastle with its own four native Scots and two more Diasporans, so fourteen in the twenty-two.
Which brings us to Chelsea, a Liverpool re-run. Stamford Bridge stadium had been opened in 1877 as an athletics ground and venue for other events. The London Caledonian Society had used it for its annual gathering. In 1898 it would host the World Shinty final between Beauly and the London Camanachd. But it appears not to have been making money, such that immediately in 1896 new owners, the Mears brothers, sons of a local builder, had offered it to a Southern League topping and still ambitious Fulham F.C..
However, clearly the offer was too demanding and there were alternatives. The club built and began to play at Craven Cottage that same year, which meant the Mears had something of white elephant, that there was talk of selling the land to the Great Western Railway but that fell through too and by 1905 the idea had already surfaced to create, despite Fulham being so close, a new football club, given the name Chelsea F.C..
And to do so, under the name of Chelsea F.C., the younger Gus Mears, a man clearly not without influence one way or another, did three things. He applied to join the Football League's First Division but was knocked back, he imported, under the captaincy of Scottish internationalist
John Tait Robertson, a squad of mainly Scots, seventeen in all (Fulham also had nine at the time) and he persuaded that same Football League to give him a place in the Second Division, replacing Doncaster Rovers. The Caledonian Chelsea team would finish third in its first season and be promoted in its second. The number of Scots would dip to five in 1909-10. The club would be relegated. The number would be increased once more to ten. The result was re-promotion, stabilisation and then an eighth-place finish. There was also a pattern and not just on-field, with all but the first promotion achieved after the arrival as manager in 1907 of Hurlford's
David Calderhead, poached from seven years at Lincoln City and who would remain in position until 1933.
